Home / Publications / News and analysis / ForIntel Research / A State Government Blindly Used AI to Draft Its Court Filing. The Citation Inside It Does Not Exist.

A State Government Blindly Used AI to Draft Its Court Filing. The Citation Inside It Does Not Exist.

A Madhya Pradesh court found the state cited a fabricated Supreme Court case to defend firing a police officer. The judge ordered state lawyers to check their citations before swearing them on affidavit.

By Foragentis teamPublished 2026-11-212 min read

In 2024, the state government dismissed a police officer in Madhya Pradesh, India, after a complaint, skipping the formal departmental inquiry a dismissal like his normally requires. When he challenged it in court, the state government's defense rested in part on a Supreme Court case it called "State of Andhra Pradesh v. S.S. Mohammad Nisar," cited as (2008) 5 SCC 230, to argue that the High Court had no power to re-examine the evidence behind his dismissal. The Madhya Pradesh High Court checked the citation. No such judgment exists. That exact citation belongs to a different case, about suspending a sentence in a criminal appeal, which has nothing to do with the question the state was arguing.

Justice Vivek Kumar Singh's bench, ruling on November 17, 2026, held that the state had "blindly resorted to the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools to draft their pleadings" and called the conduct "callous and irresponsible." The court said inserting a fictitious case "borders on actively misleading the Court" and warned against "reckless practices" going forward. It forwarded the judgment to the state's Law Secretary and its Advocate General, and told that office to make sure its lawyers verify every legal citation before swearing it on affidavit. The court set aside the officer's dismissal and ordered him reinstated, leaving the state free to run a proper inquiry if it still wants to pursue the matter.

Legal-press coverage treats this case as notable for who was on the wrong end of the fabricated citation. Fake AI-generated case law has mostly turned up before tribunals or in filings by private litigants. Here, the government itself relied on it to defend a decision that cost a person his job.

Foragentis could not independently pull the judgment text from the Madhya Pradesh High Court's own site within this review. The ruling, the quoted language, the fabricated citation, and the outcome are each reported by Bar and Bench and LawBeat, two specialist legal-press outlets with their own court reporters covering the case independently.

The fix the court ordered is not complicated. Check the citation before it goes in front of a judge. That is the same discipline a market research report owes a reader: name where a figure comes from, and say plainly where the evidence is thin, before the report is delivered rather than after someone downstream has acted on it. ForIntel reports name the sources they draw on and say plainly where the evidence is thin. A person approves the scope of each order before the research runs, and a person reads every report before it is delivered. None of that stops a government, a firm, or anyone else from skipping that check on its own. It does mean the question of where to be skeptical sits in the document itself, not in a court's finding that follows a year, or a career, later.